« Life In A Company Town | Main | Honey, I'm Still Free »

Thursday, July 03, 2014

Conscientious Objector +1

Remember when Sotomayor threw women under the bus?  Well go over the LGM and see how she's clearly redeemed herself.  Expect no other context from me.

I will, however, highlight this:

“Suppose it is wartime, there is a draft, and a Quaker is called up. Many Quakers are pacifists, and their pacifism is a tenet of their religion. Suppose the Quaker who’s been called up tells the selective service system that he’s a conscientious objector. The selective service officer to whom he makes this pitch accepts the sincerity of his refusal to bear arms and excuses him. But as the Quaker leaves the selective service office, he’s told: ‘you know this means we’ll have to draft someone in place of you’—and the Quaker replies indignantly that if the government does that, it will be violating his religious beliefs. Because his religion teaches that no one should bear arms, drafting another person in his place would make him responsible for the military activities of his replacement, and by doing so would substantially burden his own sincere religious beliefs. Would this mean that by exempting him the government had forced him to ‘trigger’ the drafting of a replacement who was not a conscientious objector, and that the Religious Freedom Restoration Act would require a draft exemption for both the Quaker and his non‐Quaker replacement?”

This is so great.  Wish I'd thought of it.


July 3, 2014 in Conscience | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Conscientious Objector +1:



Posted by: Mustang Bobby | Jul 3, 2014 9:12:51 PM

Post a comment