« Don't Blame Me, I Voted For Kodos | Main | Happiness Redux »
Thursday, March 02, 2006
Babies Are Cool
Any parent can relate tales of a wobbly toddler's endearing desire to help out. Now scientists have documented it, in a study suggesting that the capacity for altruism emerges as early as 18 months of age.
It was a simple experiment to illustrate fairly sophisticated brain development: Tots watched as psychology researcher Felix Warneken did ordinary tasks, such as using clothespins to hang some towels.
Oops, he dropped a clothespin. Video shows one overall-clad baby glancing between Warneken's face and the dropped pin before quickly crawling over, grabbing the object, pushing up to his feet and eagerly handing back the pin.
Warneken never asked for the help and didn't even say "thank you," so as not to taint the research by training youngsters to expect praise if they helped. After all, altruism means helping with no expectation of anything in return.
Over and over, whether Warneken dropped clothespins or knocked over a stack of books or lost a marker he was going to write with, each of 24 toddlers repeatedly helped within seconds — but only if it looked like Warneken needed it.
That was the key: The toddlers offered no help when he deliberately pulled a book off the stack or threw a marker on the floor, Warneken, of Germany's Max Planck Institute of Evolutionary Anthropology, reports in Thursday's edition of the journal Science.
To be altruistic, babies must have the cognitive ability to understand other people's goals plus possess what Warneken calls "pro-social motivation" — a desire to socialize.
We have two accidental "commands" in our household: 'help' and 'oops'. Cairo started the whole thing when she figured out that when a human in the kitchen said 'oops', it usually meant some food was on the floor and she would 'help' clean it up. Mex is learning the words now. Somehow I don't think dogs are being altruistic in this situation...
ntodd
March 2, 2006 | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c525c53ef00d83478567953ef
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Babies Are Cool:
Comments
I have to confess that I have deliberately dropped a piece or two (such a clumpsy cook) for my step-son's dog. But she then cleans my floor so I don't have to mop. See? It works both ways.
Posted by: ellroon | Mar 2, 2006 3:53:10 PM
If, as the research suggests, the capacity for altruism is innate, how do some families, e.g., the Bushes, so successfully stem its development across several generations? Think about it: Jenna sticking out her tongue at the press is emblematic of the whole family, from Prescott down to the younger generation. If nature gave them altruism, nurture certainly overcame it.
Posted by: Steve Bates | Mar 2, 2006 4:36:18 PM
Cut Mex a break: of course he is altruistic! He loves to lick faces and gives full-body hugs just because he thinks it makes his people happy. I'm not sure how we're gonna break it to him that a little kow-tow is all we really need...
Posted by: NTodd's Pa's wife | Mar 2, 2006 6:03:08 PM
Somehow I don't think dogs are being altruistic in this situation...
Pfui!! The doggies wanna see Daddy smile. And it works, doesn't it?
Posted by: flory | Mar 2, 2006 8:47:47 PM
This sort of helps me out. I have an arguement with a friend. My stance,
people are inherently good. His stance, we are inherently bad and only
when we find god can we begin to resolve that problem.
As they say, the "wisdom of the children" comes through again.
Posted by: EkCenTriK | Mar 3, 2006 2:17:36 AM
NTodd,
I'm starting to see this with Rosie now: I'd argue it's part mimicry, part altruism. As their skills develop, they want to use them the way that they se adults do. That can be good and bad. (eg: After years as a scholar, Thers is constitutionally incapable of reading a book without a pencil in his hand to take notes: Rosie sees this and thinks books are meant to be written in.)
People who do developmental psych tell me that there's a window during which altruism and empathy must be taught, and that's between 18 months and 3 years. If, during that time, parents don't try to teach that others have feelings and that those feelings matter, you end up with the Bushes.
Posted by: NYMary | Mar 3, 2006 6:48:11 AM
Wasn't it the horrific discovery of Romanian(?) orphans being warehoused that showed what happens to babies when neglected at that crucial stage of development? They have a crop of sociopathic adults who lack even basic empathy trying to function in their society.
And as I am a packrat and a collector of books, I recommend garage sales for children's books. My children saw me salvaging old books and treating them with care, so I lost only a few to being eaten or drawn on.
Your children are very cute btw!
Posted by: ellroon | Mar 3, 2006 1:12:25 PM



